Hungarians in Romania

Posted by Bruno on 29/03/08

Cluj Napoca, RO (View on map)

Transylvania was neither invented by Dracula`s spiritual father Bram Stoker, nor was the region`s name born out of his creativity. Transylvania has existed for many centuries before the Dracula myth came into existence. Throughout all those years, Transylvania has almost incessantly changed ownership. Before being added to Romanian territory in the wake of WWI, it had already belonged to the Roman Empire, the Ottoman Empire and the last owner before Romania: the Austrian-Hungarian Empire. The shared history with neighbouring Hungary and Austria explains why Transylvania still has a huge Hungarian and even German influence.

It leads no surprise that Transylvania`s capital Cluj-Napoca was attributed plenty of different names by all the different owners of the regions. The Romanians simply refer to it as Cluj, anybody speaking German may refer to is as Klausenburg, the Hungarians call it Kolozsvár, all after the Romans once named it Napoca. People in the streets talk a variety of languages, with Romanian, French, English, German and Hungarian among the most frequently heard. Multicultural Cluj is nowadays the most metropolitan and multicultural city of Romania, in line with its heritage from the early 1900s. The multicultural development was halted after the Second World War, when communists wiped out all difference between the different ethnic groups. Even after the revolution, an anti-Hungarian nationalist mayor by the name of Gheorghe Funar denied Cluj`s multicultural nature. By doing so, he unintentionally discouraged international firms to invest in the region and even slowed down the economic development in the city. Recent years have shown major improvements in the local economy and also in the relations between the Romanians and the Hungarians residing in Cluj. The Romanians and Hungarians are not the only ones to take advantage of the new situation. Cluj`s universities attract students from across Europe and beyond, while foreign investment is thriving. Within five years time, Cluj has transformed from a greyish regional capital back into the intellectual and international centre it already was a century ago. This time with newly paved streets, cafés, shoe shops, banks and an abundant availability of any product or service one can think of. Outside the city of Cluj Napoca, there are still some places where accounts have not yet been entirely settled. Two Romanian provinces East of Cluj, Harghita and Covasna, have a Hungarian majority that would be very much in favour of independence, even though their independent state would be surrounded by Romanian territory. Transylvania itself already has similar ambitions, and if both favours were granted, Romania would become a patchwork of countries within countries. Foreign languages Whenever Alex (21) travels through areas that have a dominant Hungarian population, he hardly feels at home in his own country. `On the whole, things are OK. I have many Hungarian friends and even if they sometimes start speaking Hungarian among themselves in the presence of others, that`s still alright with me. But then, if you walk into a shop and they simply refuse to speak Romanian, that annoys me quite a bit. Or for example yesterday: I walked into a bookshop with a Hungarian owner. When I started speaking Romanian, all of a sudden I needed to leave my bag at the entrance. And we have a Hungarian king standing on the main square in the city centre of Cluj. It`s not a problem, but you wouldn`t see anything like that in another country.` `Talking stereotypes, Hungarians seem to have a preference for the colour green and they are good at cooking goulash. They have different first names than we Romanians do, with Istvan and Arpad ranking among the most stereotypical ones. Romanian Hungarians are not known for being very strong at foreign languages, and many of them don`t even speak English.` Bogdan (25) think that Hungarians are like Romanians, with the exception that the Hungarians `forever think that they will be taken advantage of whenever any authority takes a decision. Maybe it`s a legacy from the communist times, when they were treated as second range citizens. But so was everybody, so that shouldn`t explain the difference.` I ask him what his parents would say if he came home with a Hungarian girlfriend. He replies that they would probably not have any problem with that, as long as the girl behaves like a normal citizen without feeling prosecuted. Trilingual Mirjam (21, photo) is a clear exception to the stereotypical Romanian Hungarian: `I speak both Hungarian and Romanian fluently, but I prefer to formulate my reflections in English. Most of my education was in English, I guess that`s why. Most of my friends are actually Americans, not Romanians, but I think the lack of sympathy between Romanians and Hungarians is mostly something from the past. Maybe some old people still hate each other, but that would be on the individual level. There are many mixed couples, even though most Romanians think Hungarian is way to complicated to even try and learn it.` `Beside the language differences, Romanians and Hungarians belong to different churches. Hungarians are mostly catholic, Romanians are mostly orthodox. The Romanians think they are more religious than we are, but I don`t really believe that. They use the church for everything, up until match making services. Much of it has little to do with religion.` Codruta (28) is Romanian but knows a few words of Hungarian: `I don`t have a lot of access to it though. My Hungarian Romanian friends always switch to Romanian whenever I`m around, so I only get to hear it in the streets. There is something interesting about the way Romanians look at Hungarians. Romanians blame them for being too structurised, but at the same time, the Romanians from this part of the country are subject to the same prejudices from Romanians from the rest of the country. It works both ways, we in the north don`t always speak about Romanians from the South in a very flattering way. The money is made in the Western part of the country, but it is spent in the South. We obviously wonder what happens to all the money our region is contributing to the rest of the country.` Respect Aziz (34) is one of the approximately 1 000 Tunisians living in Cluj. The French university for Medicine and Pharmacy attracts quite some North African medicine studies. Aziz also came as a student, but ended up marrying his Hungarian Romanian wife. He now works as a business man in clothes. As a bit of an outsider to the Hungarian-Romanian struggle, he summarises the issue as follows: `Romanians in general have a lot of respect for the Hungarians. But there`s always a little hate in their respect. Hungarians are thought of as more powerful, more serious and more goal-oriented. In business, you can count on their promises, which is not necessarily the case with Romanians. Obviously, that quickly makes Hungarians thought of as rich and arrogant, especially those who are unwilling or unable to speak Romanian or otherwise insist on their non-Romanian roots.`

4 Responses to Hungarians in Romania »»

  1. Comment by Daniel Antal | 2008/03/30 at 20:36:46

    I think you misunderstand the position of Hungarians in Romania.

    “Two Romanian provinces East of Cluj, Harghita and Covasna, have a Hungarian majority that would be very much in favour of independence, even though their independent state would be surrounded by Romanian territory”.

    In fact, the Hungarians have two major parties, the parliamentary RMDSZ and the more radical MPP, but neither of them nor the majority of Romanian Hungarians want an independence. (I am Hungarian, but I have never ever heard of such a claim). The political aim of the two Hungarian parties are the same: they would like to form an autonomous region within Romania, similarly to South Tirol in Italy or Catalonia in Spain. One of the official reasons why Romania is not recognizing Kosovo’s independence is that the Ahtisaari-plan (not incorporated in the Kosovar constitution) promised such minority rights to the Kosovar Serbs that Hungarians want in Romania.

    The situation is similar to many Balkan counties. The two major ethnic groups, first Hungarians than Romanians tried to form a nation state in a multi-ethnic environment since the beginning of the Central European nationalism. The Hungarians had the upper hand until 1918 - Transylvania was ruled by the Hungarian King or Hungarian principals almost all the time since 1000 - and after 1918 the Romanians took over.

    Actually Transylvania has lot much of its multi-ethnic character during these nationalistic struggles: most of the Germans, the third biggest ethnic group have emigrated in the 20th century, and almost all the Jews were killed during the second World War. In the last three decades maybe half of the working age Hungarian population also emigrated to Hungary.

    But things may be changing, and Transylvania may regain some of its multicultural character due to its fascinating growth. In the last year Romanian-born Hungarians started to move back to Transylvania in droves.

  2. Comment by Emil Per. | 2008/07/07 at 09:26:36

    Daniel Antal:

    “In the last year Romanian-born Hungarians started to move back to Transylvania in droves.”

    I might be wrong, but my experience in Budapest was that Rumanian “Rumanians” were more welcome than Hungarian “Rumanians” … I am not Hungarian, btw.

    Rumanian Hungarians wanting independence ? If they do, they keep it secret. The only people to claim that Hungarians from Rumania want independence are the Greater Romania Party and their ilk … and sometimes I believe that the “more radical” MPP has a deal with GRP to muddy the waters and get votes by inventing enemies.

    From the article:
    “I speak both Hungarian and Romanian fluently, but I prefer to formulate my reflections in English” — it happens quite a lot these days: English is just a lot more useful.

  3. ME
    Comment by ME | 2008/09/07 at 17:50:17

    You have no clue what you’re talking about.
    Transylvania is hungarian and always will be hungarian in spite of the Trianon treaty.

  4. Comment by Zozi | 2009/07/17 at 19:12:47

    Antal, kérlek írd meg magyarul is hozzászólásodat. Magyarként engem is érdekel a téma, de nem tudok román nyelven, a webszótár meg érthetetlenül fordítja le. Köszönöm.

    [WORDPRESS HASHCASH] The poster sent us ‘0 which is not a hashcash value.


Leave a Reply »»

*
To prove you're a person (not a spam script), type the security word shown in the picture.
Anti-Spam Image

Powered by WP Hashcash

Advertisement